Rent or buy, worked through
The answer. For a $450,000 home against $2,400 a month in rent, buying comes out about $100,000 ahead after 30 years: $1.29M of net worth for the buyer against $1.19M for the renter. But renting is ahead for the first 17 years, and buying pulls ahead for good only in year 18 (2044). So the honest answer is: buy only if you expect to stay 18 years or more. Every figure here is the base case on the Stage, where each assumption can be moved.
A fair race
Both households start with the same cash, $103,500. The buyer spends it on a 20% down payment ($90,000) and 3% closing costs ($13,500). The renter puts the same $103,500 into an index portfolio returning 7% a year.
After that, each month, whichever household pays less for housing invests the difference in the same portfolio. That one rule keeps the comparison fair: neither side gets to spend money the other saves. At any year's end, net worth is what each would walk away with if it sold everything: the home after 6% selling costs and the loan, the portfolio after capital gains tax at 15%.
What a month costs
The buyer borrows $360,000 over 30 years at 7.32%, the average rate Freddie Mac reported on October 22, 2026. The payment of principal and interest is fixed at $2,473 a month for the life of the loan. Everything else grows with the home's value, set at 3.5% a year:
| First month | Owning | Renting |
|---|---|---|
| Mortgage payment | $2,473 | |
| Property tax (1.1% a year) | $413 | |
| Maintenance (1% a year) | $375 | |
| Insurance (0.5% a year) | $188 | |
| Tax saving from itemizing | −$169 | |
| Rent | $2,400 | |
| Total | $3,279 | $2,400 |
Owning costs $879 more a month at first, and the renter invests that $879. Rent, though, grows 3.5% a year while the payment stays put. By year 18, rent is $4,307 a month against $4,223 for owning, and from then on it is the buyer who invests the difference. That is why the break-even year and the year rent overtakes owning land close together.
The costs people forget
Over 30 years, owning costs $693,000 beyond the loan itself:
| Over 30 years | Cost |
|---|---|
| Property tax | $256,000 |
| Maintenance | $232,000 |
| Insurance | $116,000 |
| Selling the home (6% in year 30) | $76,000 |
| Closing costs to buy | $13,500 |
The buyer also pays $530,000 of interest. Much of the homeowner's tax break never arrives. Interest and state and local taxes help only when, together, they beat the standard deduction, and the SALT cap, $40,400 in 2026, falls to $10,000 from 2030. Here the saving is $2,024 in the first year, $1,867 and $1,702 in the next two, and nothing after: $5,600 in all.
How the buyer pulls ahead
The renter's lead is about $39,000 after the first year, mostly the closing costs the buyer paid and the selling costs a sale would bring. It shrinks slowly, to $29,000 by year 10, as the home's value grows and the loan is paid down. It closes in year 18 and grows from there: a home worth $1.26M in year 30, owned outright, is worth $1.15M after selling costs and tax, and the buyer by then has $149,000 invested as well.
When the answer flips
The 30-year answer rests on a few assumptions, and it is close enough that a modest change reverses it. Holding everything else at the base case, renting wins if:
| Assumption | Base case | Renting wins |
|---|---|---|
| Rent growth a year | 3.5% | below 3.3% |
| Rent a month | $2,400 | below $2,335 |
| Home price | $450,000 | above $463,000 |
| Investment return a year | 7.0% | above 7.3% |
| Maintenance a year | 1.0% | above 1.2% |
| Property tax a year | 1.1% | above 1.28% |
| Mortgage rate | 7.32% | above 7.74% |
| Home price growth a year | 3.5% | below 2.5% |
Rent growth moves the answer most: a point either way swings the 30-year result from a $306,000 lead for renting to a $579,000 lead for buying. The mortgage rate and home prices decide how long you must stay. At 6.5% and 3.5% growth, buying pulls ahead in year 10; at 8%, homes must grow 4% a year before buying wins at all.
What the model leaves out
It assumes a 30-year fixed loan, a married couple filing jointly in the 24% bracket with $10,000 of other state and local taxes, and the 2026 standard deduction of $32,200, both growing 2.5% a year. A couple may take up to $500,000 of gain on their home tax-free. It ignores mortgage insurance, moving costs, and how much either household values staying put or being free to leave. The datasets in the Model tab hold its full monthly ledger, and the script that writes them.