Nestwise Q3 campaign review
The finding. Nestwise spent $1.2M on paid campaigns in the 13 weeks from 6 July, and the 39,081 people who subscribed through them will bring $2.46M of first-year revenue: $2.05 back for every dollar, at $30.71 a subscriber. Podcasts earned the most for each dollar and TikTok the least, although TikTok drew more clicks for its money than any other channel. Moving money from TikTok and YouTube to Meta, podcasts, and search would add about $135k next quarter on the same budget. Every figure here is live on the Stage, where the budget can be moved channel by channel.
What the quarter returned
The figures come from the campaign team's own export of Q3: each channel's weekly spend, impressions, clicks, trial starts, and paid subscribers from the ad platforms, matched to first-year revenue from the subscription records.
| Channel | Spend | Click rate | Cost per subscriber | First-year revenue | Back for each $1 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Podcasts | $120k | 0.60% | $24.40 | $393k | $3.28 |
| Paid search | $300k | 3.21% | $21.97 | $896k | $2.99 |
| Meta | $360k | 0.92% | $36.34 | $637k | $1.77 |
| YouTube | $180k | 0.79% | $40.71 | $284k | $1.58 |
| TikTok | $240k | 1.79% | $38.85 | $248k | $1.03 |
| All channels | $1.2M | 1.44% | $30.71 | $2.46M | $2.05 |
Paid search brought in the most revenue, but podcasts returned the most for each dollar: host-read spots reach few people and cost $3.65 a click, yet the listeners who come through them start trials and keep paying far more often than anyone else.
The trap: clicks are not customers
TikTok looked like the quarter's star in the weekly click reports. A hundred dollars there bought 357 clicks, more than three times what search or Meta bought, and the budget-challenge video had a 2.13% click rate. On that strength its weekly budget nearly doubled from 27 July. But few of those clicks became paying subscribers, and each one brought $40 in its first year against $66 from search: TikTok returned $1.03 for each dollar, barely paying for itself. After the budget rose, its cost per subscriber climbed from $32.30 to $40.14, the falling return the reallocation below is built on.
The change that worked
On 24 August the team switched Meta's campaigns from optimising for trial starts to optimising for paid subscriptions. Meta's cost per subscriber fell 36%, from $44.96 in the weeks before to $28.99 in the weeks after, with no change in budget. Its click rate even fell slightly; what changed is who the platform showed the ads to.
Messages
Across every channel that ran them, "Budget for two" earned $2.35 a dollar and "Save $40 a month" $1.61. The best creative of the quarter, brand search terms at $5.51 a dollar, mostly catches people already looking for Nestwise and cannot be scaled by spending more. The host-read spots on money shows, at $3.88, can.
Next quarter's budget
Each channel's revenue rises with its spend, but every extra dollar returns less than the one before. The Stage fits that curve to each channel's 13 weeks, as revenue = k × spendb; Meta is fitted on the weeks since its switch, the way it runs now. The bend b is about 0.5 for search, YouTube, and podcasts, and about 0.7 for Meta and TikTok. Each channel is kept between half and one and a half times its Q3 spend, near the weeks the curves were fitted on.
Within those limits, the best split of the same $1.2M is:
| Channel | Q3 spend | Recommended | Next $1 returns |
|---|---|---|---|
| Meta | $360k | $520k | $1.44 |
| Paid search | $300k | $315k | $1.43 |
| Podcasts | $120k | $155k | $1.43 |
| TikTok | $240k | $120k | $0.88 |
| YouTube | $180k | $90k | $1.17 |
At Q3's mix, next quarter would return a projected $2.64M; at the recommended mix, $2.77M, or $2.31 a dollar against $2.20. Cutting TikTok and YouTube by $210k gives up $182k of revenue, and the same money moved to Meta, podcasts, and search earns $317k. TikTok and YouTube stop at half their Q3 spend only because the model is not trusted further from what was tested; their next dollar still returns less than the others'.
What we recommend
- Keep Meta on paid-subscription optimisation, and give it the largest share of the budget.
- Halve TikTok and YouTube, and judge TikTok on revenue, not clicks, from now on.
- Grow host-read podcasts on money shows, and lead with "Budget for two" wherever it can run.
The projection is a simple model of thirteen weeks of data, not a promise: rerun it on the Stage as next quarter's weeks come in.